Search this catalogue
 [?]
 [?]
 [?]
 [?]
print this page

Catalog entry

inv. 32
Coast of Maine
Maine Coastal View, A Maine Inlet; Maine Inlet
(with Mary Blood Mellen)
1850s
Oil on round canvas
14 1/2 in. (36.8 cm) (diameter)
Signed verso: F.H. Lane
On view at the Cape Ann Museum

Commentary

This fascinating little painting is the only verified, signed collaboration between Lane and his student Mary Mellen. Lane appears to have been lending his hand to a Mellen painting, not vice versa. An invented landscape is an atypical composition for Lane, but not for Mellen—at least not based on her later work. The infrared scan (below) further supports the hypothesis that this is a Mellen composition: there is no visible pencil underdrawing. This was unusual for Lane, though common for Mellen.

The sky appears all Lane: it has a beautiful subtle gradation across its spectrum from blue through pink to the yellow at the horizon. It has real depth and envelops the distant island and the water in a hazy glow. Mellen herself struggled to produce this level of subtlety.

The rock cliffs framing the central water are a Mellen motif; they're very common in her later work, as is the manner in which the rocks are built up with alternating brushstrokes—particularly noticeable in the infrared scan. Yet the color is nicely varied in both the rocks and the foreground foliage and is well tuned to the sky. 

This is an intensely romantic painting; it's almost a confection in its golden glow and the carefully framed cliffs that surround the placid water. The round format only accentuates the romantic quality. A smartly dressed man is poling a little sailing craft with slack sails towards an apparent landing. One imagines that a young woman will alight and that there will be a picnic, perhaps with some poetry read aloud on a blanket in the slumberous, idyllic light. This hypothetical storyline would have been in keeping with the sentimental engravings and commercial art of the era. The painting is reminiscent of that aesthetic. 

In other works by Lane where we see stylistic evidence of Mellen’s hand, she has painted the sky, waves, or rocks in the manner of Lane, acting as his assistant and emulating his style, albeit not as skillfully. She also did direct copies of his work during his lifetime, often in multiples. We do not know when she started doing her own compositions, whether during Lane’s lifetime or afterwards. 

This painting, Coast of Maine, is a successful collaboration, regardless of who did what. One wonders how it came to be, and if there are any others like it. It presents a fascinating window into a working relationship between Lane and Mellen about which we know too little—as yet.

– Sam Holdsworth

[+] See More

Supplementary Images

Verso shows barely legible signatures F H Lane and M. B. Mellen painted in green.
Photo: Alison Anholt
© Cape Ann Museum
This infrared image of the Coast of Maine has very brushy paint application and lacks the underdrawi... [more]ng that typically is seen under the paint layer in Lane's compositions. – Marcia Steele
Photo: J. Neubecker, Cleveland Museum of Art
© Cape Ann Museum
 

Explore catalog entries by keywords view all keywords »

Subject Types:   Coastal Scene »

Historical Materials
Below is historical information related to the Lane work above. To see complete information on a subject on the Historical Materials page, click on the subject name (in bold and underlined).

[ top]

Please see also: Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen 

Mary Blood Mellen has emerged as one of the most talented artists to work on Cape Ann in the years immediately preceding the Civil War. Born in Vermont and raised in Sterling, Massachusetts, Mellen attended a girls' academy where she studied the art of painting in watercolor. The circumstances under which she and Lane met remain uncertain; however, by the 1850s they knew each other, and Mellen would soon begin using Lane's drawings and paintings as the basis for her own works.

Like many women artists of her generation, Mellen was a copyist, and a growing body of evidence indicates that Lane gave his student free access to his works. While evocative of Lane's paintings, Mellen's exhibit her own distinct palette, treatment of space, and level of detail. (1) 

Mellen made direct copies of more than half a dozen of Lane's favorite subjects: Gloucester Harbor, Norman's Woe, A Storm Breaking Away: Vessel Slipping her Cable, Entrance of Somes Sound, Two Ships in Rough Water, and as noted above, the Blood Family Homestead.

Lane's original of Two Ships (location unknown) was purchased by James H. Mansfield, whose sister described it as "one of the most beautiful Lanes I have ever seen—a picture of a barque dismasted, and rolling in a heavy sea. The touch was very soft and beautiful." Another Lane follower and copyist, the Gloucester artist D. Jerome Elwell, said, "that sky was painted con amore." When Lane died, Mellen's copy was said to have been on his easel at Duncan's Point.

In addition, there were other subjects Mellen painted multiple times, most notably A Smart Blow, Ten Pound Island at Sunset, and Owl's Head. These vary in quality from refined to stiffer and weaker interpretations. It makes one pause over Stevens's frequent phrase written on a number of Lane's drawings, "Paintings made from this drawing" for several listed clients.

– John Wilmerding

(1) Label, Cape Ann Museum, Gloucester, Massachusetts.

publication
1863 Gloucester Telegraph 12.26.1863
12.26.1863
Newspaper
Gloucester Telegraph

"The Cape Ann Sanitary Fair: [Thursday in the Curiosity Room] We noticed and particularly admired a beautiful wreath of Wax Flowers, the work of a lady artist (Mrs. Charles Mellen) who not only excels in this delicate art, but adds to it the genius so rare in women, of a high rank in oil painting. One of her landscape scenes hangs in the same room. We are happy and grateful to acknowledge again a new donation of a Painting from Mr. Lane, at half price. subject: "Little Good Harbor Beach." This, like the former, was sold at raffle and will realize to the Fair a handsome amount... The following articles were drawn in raffle: Mr. Lane's Painting of a "View from the Loaf," $100-Capt. David W. Low at one of the Town Meetings held during the Summer, the volumes presented to the Town by the City of Gloucester, Eng.,were exhibited, and the Selectmen were instructed to acknowledge the receipt of them. They did so, and also forwarded one of Lane's colored engravings of Gloucester Harbor, and one of Walling's maps of the town. [Friday] 2nd picture of Mr. Lane's, "Good Harbor Beach," $100- Mrs. Eli F. Stacy."

[+]
chart
Blood-Mellen Family Tree
Stephanie Buck
2007
Book table

From Sarah Dunlap and Stephanie Buck, Fitz Henry Lane: Family and Friends (Gloucester, MAChurch & Mason Publishing; in association with the Cape Ann Historical Museum2007), Appendix G: Family Trees:164–66.

[+]
artwork
Entrance of Somes Sound from Southwest Harbor
Mary Blood Mellen
c.1850
Oil on canvas
14 1/4 x 20 1/2 in.
Farnsworth Art Museum, Rockland, Maine, Gift of Wayne P. and Virginia B. Libhart, 2005
[+]
artwork
Moonlight View of Gloucester Harbor
Probably by Mary Blood Mellen, or possibly by D. Jerome Elwell
1870s
Oil on canvas
13 x 20 1/4 in.
Shelburne Museum, Vt.

This picture is less clearly an exact copy and more of a variation on the theme. It could be by either Mellen or D. Jerome Elwell, a Gloucester artist of a generation younger than Lane who very much admired the older man's work and consciously began his own career working in Lane's style. In this case there is an obvious hardness of surfaces, an over-meticulousness in the lighting of details, and an obviousness in the stark silhouettes—all atypical for Lane.

Elwell is a more complicated personality, but his copies after Lane are equally challenging. One was his recreation of Lane's 1856 view of Gloucester burned in the 1864 fire. After Lane's death, Elwell also "touched upon" several pictures. Others in the family, like Kilby Elwell, had artistic tastes, and as a boy, Jerome began to make pencil copies after other works.

Much younger than Lane, D. Jerome Elwell completed high school in Gloucester in the last years of Lane's life and shortly after went to Antwerp to study. This travel was made possible by the generosity of Samuel Sawyer, a patron as well of Lane's in the 1860s. During the seventies Elwell traveled around the Low Countries and elsewhere in Europe, at one time (it was said) sharing a studio with Whistler in Venice. Like Lane before him, he cultivated a taste for twilight and moonlight effects, though Elwell's style tended to be harsher and his colors more metallic.

– John Wilmerding

Also filed under: Elwell, D. Jerome »

[+]
PDF
view ]
publication
Report on scholars' gathering in association with the exhibition Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries
John Wilmerding, Karen Quinn, Marcia Steele et al.
November 15, 2007
Unpublished report
Cape Ann Museum, Spanierman Gallery

Report on Scholars' Gathering in Association with the Exhibition Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries, organized by Cape Ann Museum, Gloucester, Massachusetts, in partnership with Spanierman Gallery, and curated by Professor John Wilmerding.

[+]
artwork
Ten Pound Island at Sunset
Mary Blood Mellen
1870s
Oil on canvas
8 x 14 in.
Private collection

The questions about the Ten Pound Island series are further compounded by at least one version that was reworked by Elwell. An inscription on the reverse—presumably in Lane's hand—of his Ten Pound Island at Sunset reads, "Composition, F.H. Lane to J.L. Stevens." Beneath, Elwell wrote: "D. Jerome Elwell touched upon, March 13, '91."

Elwell had overpainted some of Lane's sky with even more intense and hotter cadmium reds and pinks, presumably more in keeping with later Victorian taste. The Mellen copies also tend toward a lighter and paler palette, but her versions are distinguishable ultimately for their softer rendering of rock formations and boat rigging in particular. Seen in isolation, the best of them seem very close to Lane's own hand.

– John Wilmerding

[+]
PDF
view ]
publication
The Lane-Mellen Association
John Wilmerding
2007
Book essay

In John Wilmerding, Fitz Henry Lane and Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries (New York: Spanierman, 2007), 40-43.

[+]
PDF
view ]
manuscript
Will of Fitz H. Lane
FItz. H. Lane
October 3, 1865
Essex County Probate Records, Volume 424, Leaves 34 & 35

The will disposed of Lane's property (including watch and diamond breast pin), his monetary assets, and gave to the city of Gloucester a painting of the Old Fort. Joseph Stevens, Jr. and T. Sewall Lancaster were named executors. It was signed by Lane on March 10, 1865.

[+]

Provenance (Information known to date; research ongoing.)

Exhibition History

2007 Cape Ann Museum: Cape Ann Historical Museum, Gloucester, Massachusetts, The Mysteries of Fitz Henry Lane, no. 45, ill., p. 99.

Published References

Moses 1991: "Mary B. Mellen and Fitz Hugh Lane," pp. 828, 832. ⇒ includes text
Craig 2006a: Fitz H. Lane: An Artist's Voyage through Nineteenth-Century America, fig. 87.
Wilmerding 2007a: Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries, no. 45, p. 99. ⇒ includes text

Related historical materials

Contemporary Artists
Citation: "Coast of Maine, 1850s (inv. 32)." Fitz Henry Lane Online. Cape Ann Museum. http://fitzhenrylaneonline.org/catalog/entry.php?id=32 (accessed December 18, 2017).
Record last updated April 5, 2016. Please note that the information on this and all pages is periodically reviewed and subject to change.
Please share your knowledge with us: click here to leave feedback.